|
Rossini's Otello
The Guardian
'Rossini's Otello is an opera with a notorious reputation... the opera is twaddle when put beside Verdi's much later version; and it requires no fewer than three star tenors... all of whom have to sing some of the most impossibly gruelling music ever written. The revelation of The Royal Opera's new production, however, is that most of the charges flung at the opera are erroneous. Shakespeare is not so much travestied as cogently distilled along neoclassical lines...
As for the three tenors, Covent Garden has unquestionably found them - and boy can they sing. Rossini lets his Otello seduce, enchant and rave over the fearsome extreme of two-and-a-half octaves. Bruce Ford negotiates this terrifying range with consummate ease and minimal showiness... Juan Diego Florez is cast as Rodrigo... The tessitura is implacably high, the coloratura treacherous. Florez spins it out with a staggering perfection of tone. Octavio Arevalo's Iago completes the triumvirate. Hearing this trio in action is imperative.'
The Times
‘Even Rossini enthusiasts admit that not all the music in the earlier
acts shows him at his best, though this aristocrat among composers was
incapable of writing notes that were less than graceful and civilised in
the broadest sense. But the good bits are very good indeed, with many a
pointer to later operas - the Otello-Iago letter duet is Rigoletto's
Vendetta in more than embryo - and the third act is top-drawer Rossini
throughout. I would argue that his treatment of Desdemona's Willow Song
is far more imaginative than Verdi's.
So Rossini's Otello needs doing, occasionally, and I cannot imagine it
being better done than it is by the Royal Opera. It has sensibly
borrowed Pier Luigi Pizzi's handsome production from Pesaro: Renaissance
sets and costumes, discreet "operatic" direction - this Rossini would
not repay deconstruction. And given that the Naples company for whom
Rossini wrote it in 1816 had more tenors on the roster than you could
shake a stick at - you need five! - they have assembled a dream cast.
Bruce Ford has made the enigmatic title role his own. It is enigmatic in
that it almost sounds as if you need a baritone (it goes very low), but
one who can fling off top Cs as well. All this Ford can do with ease,
and he was in exceptionally warm, strong voice on Monday.
Rodrigo is a more conventional Rossini tenor role - ie, high and
florid - and Ford's Pesaro colleague Juan Diego Flórez was simply
sensational, every note in even the most intricate piece of coloratura
knitting securely voiced. These two hurling defiance and top notes at
each other is the stuff of which opera is made, or used to be.
Mariella Devia is an impeccable stylist and technician with a most
beautiful voice: her Desdemona was one long, limpid stream of vocal
delight. And so on: the tenor Octavio Arévalo turned Iago into a major
role through sheer gumption and a bass of Alastair Miles's stature was
engaged for the small role of Desdemona's father: he was superb. Timothy
Robinson sang the Gondolier's offstage song with Rossinian grace.
The wise, unobtrusive conductor Gianluigi Gelmetti gave his singers
every support while granting the score its full dramatic weight. A great
evening.'
|